Pizza restaurants

Cimarron House of Pizza

4.4 96 reviews 4:30 AM - 8:00 PM 253 9th St, Cimarron, NM 87714, United States

Discover this place

Cimarron House of Pizza, nestled in the heart of Cimarron, New Mexico, has quickly become a beloved dining stop for hikers and pizza enthusiasts alike. Located at 253 9th St, this cozy pizza haven specializes in a variety of mouth-watering pies, including standout selections like the Big 10, 6 Meat Deluxe, and Bacon Chicken Ranch, each priced around $14.00.

Patrons rave about the outdoor seating, where picnic tables in the fresh air create a casual atmosphere enhancing the dining experience. Reviews highlight the swift service, with many praising the prompt delivery, particularly to those recovering from long treks, like the popular Philmont Scout Ranch visitors. Customer Ana Schaus mentions, "Speedy delivery in 30 minutes without prescheduling," showcasing their commitment to convenience.

With a diverse menu that also includes hot dogs and Frito pies, Cimarron House of Pizza caters to a variety of tastes. Many guests, including Bryan Horling, appreciate the unique ordering system via a doorbell at the corner window, offering a personal touch that adds to the charm. Whether you're indulging in a calzone or sharing a pizza after a day on the trails, this pizza shop undoubtedly leaves patrons satisfied and eager to return.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Seating

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Cimarron House of Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Cimarron House of Pizza

4.4

96 reviews

100%

20%

14%

Review highlights

Based on 96 reviews

Cimarron House of Pizza is widely appreciated for its convenient location near Philmont Scout Ranch, making it a popular choice for hikers and outdoor enthusiasts. Customers frequently commend the fast and friendly service, with orders taken directly at the window or by phone, avoiding automated systems. The outdoor seating options, including picnic tables and nearby park areas, enhance the casual dining experience. The menu caters well to groups, offering ample portions that satisfy larger parties, along with accommodating dietary preferences like gluten-free crusts. While some find the pizza reminiscent of frozen styles, most reviews highlight its reliability and suitability as a quick, satisfying meal after long treks, establishing the place as a valued local stop for visitors and scouts alike.

Ev Mill

Oct 18, 2025

Tasted just like a frozen pizza- just what our crew needed after a 12 day trek

Bryan Horling

Oct 17, 2025

Our troop stopped here after our Philmont hike. The food was great - I had the calzone and really enjoyed it. Order by ringing the doorbell at the corner window, and seating is outside at the picnic tables

Kirstin Holfelder

Sep 25, 2025

Delicious pizza just off main street. Order at the window, eat at the picnic tables or across the street at the park. Fast, friendly and worth a stop.

Brodie DeHass

Sep 21, 2025

Three jumbos and one medium fed 9 hungry Philmont hikers. Perfect pizza shop for crews from Philmont. 624LL 2021 ate here after our trek. Pizza was very popular from our guys. Some said it was the best they ever had. A gluten free crust was appreciated by one of our crew. Thanks For Dinner!

Ana Schaus

Aug 08, 2025

The best pizza for Philmont Scout Ranch. Speedy delivery 30 minutes without prescheduling. No need to schedule hours ahead like at the Philmont cantina. Take orders over the phone by a real person and not a machine. Super fast and friendly. Only place to order pizza for those at Philmont Scout Ranch.

Chris Bradburry

Jul 26, 2025

Essentially a tasty pizza restaurant being run out of someone’s house where you eat in their front yard! Pizza was awesome though. Good price.

Edgardo Marzan

Jul 20, 2025

This place is amazing! You get to eat delicious pizza with a great view of the mountains. When my family went there, we met a crew of sea scouts that had just finished a trek at Philmont. It was a great experience meeting sea scouts for the first time. Lastly, this was one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten!